Skip to content
Knoativ

Ecommerce strategy

Shopping Cart Abandonment: Why Shoppers Leave, How to Recover

Why about 70% of carts are abandoned, the checkout fixes that matter and how to win them back.

Knoativ TeamRetail CX Research12 min read

Young shopper paying by phone at a colorful gift store checkout

Shopping cart abandonment is when a shopper adds items to an online cart, or starts checkout, and leaves without buying. The cart abandonment rate is the share of carts created that never become orders. Across 50 studies compiled by Baymard Institute, the average is about 70%, so most carts on most stores are never paid for.

Some of that is shoppers browsing, comparing or saving items for later, and no checkout fix will change it. The rest is abandonment your store causes: a surprise fee, a slow page, a promo code that fails, a cart that empties when the shopper switches from app to laptop. This guide is about that second group: why it happens, what it costs, the checkout optimization fixes that matter and how to win back an abandoned cart without annoying the customer.

What is shopping cart abandonment and what is a normal cart abandonment rate?

Shopping cart abandonment is a cart created but not purchased; the cart abandonment rate is abandoned carts divided by carts created. A rate around 70% is typical, so judge your store against its own trend and its checkout steps, not against zero.

70.22%is the average documented online shopping cart abandonment rate, calculated from 50 studies by Baymard Institute.

Measure two rates, not one. Cart abandonment counts everyone who added an item and left, including browsers. Checkout abandonment counts only shoppers who started checkout and left before paying. The second is where your store design, fees and payment options do the damage, so it is the better number to manage week by week.

Split both by device, by new versus returning customer and by traffic source. A mobile checkout abandonment rate far above desktop usually points to a form or payment problem, not to customer intent.

Why do shoppers abandon carts?

Shoppers abandon carts mostly because the final cost surprises them, delivery is too slow, the checkout asks too much or they do not trust it. Retailers with stores and apps add a second set of reasons the standard lists miss.

Baymard Institute asks US online shoppers who abandoned a checkout why they left. Excluding the 42% who were just browsing, the leading answers were:

Reason for abandoning during checkoutShare of shoppersWhat it usually means in practice
Extra costs too high (shipping, tax, fees)40%The total changed at the last step
Delivery was too slow20%Delivery date or slot shown too late, or too far out
Did not trust the site with card details19%Unfamiliar payment page, missing trust signals
The site wanted me to create an account18%No guest checkout, or login forced before payment
Too long or complicated checkout17%Too many fields and steps, especially on mobile
Website had errors or crashed17%Slow pages, timeouts, payment errors
Returns policy was not satisfactory13%Policy hidden or unclear at the moment of purchase
Could not see or calculate the total up front12%No cost estimate in the cart
Credit card was declined10%Fraud rules too strict, no retry or alternative
Not enough payment methods9%Missing wallets, buy now pay later or local methods

Source: Baymard Institute. Shoppers could give more than one reason.

Five retail reasons the top lists skip

Survey lists are written for pure online stores. Retailers with stores, apps and loyalty programs lose carts in ways a shopper would describe simply as "it didn't work".

  • Stock that disappears at checkout. The item was in stock on the product page and sold out by the payment step, because another channel sold it first. Our guide to retail inventory management explains why.
  • No delivery or pickup slot. Grocery and same-day shoppers fill a basket, then find no slot until Thursday. The cart was never the problem; capacity was.
  • Promo codes that fail. The code from the email works on the website but not in the app, or fails without saying why. Many shoppers leave to search for a better code and never come back.
  • Loyalty points that do not apply. A member expects to pay part of the order with points, and checkout cannot see the balance or the member price.
  • A cart that does not follow the shopper. Items added in the app on the commute are missing on the laptop at home. Starting again is the easiest moment to stop. This is the core gap explained in what omnichannel means for a retailer.

What does an abandoned cart cost?

An abandoned cart costs the margin you would have earned plus the ad spend already paid to bring that shopper in. Small checkout improvements are worth a lot, because they apply to every cart, every day.

Here is a worked example. Every figure is illustrative; use your own analytics.

Line (illustrative)CalculationResult
Carts created per monthFrom analytics20,000
Abandoned carts20,000 × 70%14,000
Value left in abandoned carts14,000 × $90 average cart$1,260,000
Extra orders if checkout fixes cut abandonment by 3 points20,000 × 3%600 orders
Extra monthly revenue600 × $90$54,000
Extra yearly revenue$54,000 × 12$648,000

The value left in abandoned carts is a headline, not a target. Most of it was never going to convert. The line worth managing is the second one from the bottom: a few points of abandonment you cause, fixed for good. Room to improve is real: Baymard Institute estimates the average large ecommerce site could gain a 35.26% increase in conversion rate through better checkout design alone.

Find the carts your checkout is losing. In a free cart recovery review, we walk through your checkout and win-back flow on your own store, mark where shoppers drop out and show how LyraCX Commerce keeps one cart, live stock and synced promos and loyalty across app, web and store. Book your free cart recovery review.

Checkout optimization: which fixes reduce cart abandonment most?

The checkout optimization fixes that pay back fastest show the full cost early, remove forced steps, keep pages fast and make every promise (stock, slot, promo, points) true before payment. Work through them in this order.

  1. Show the total early. Put delivery cost, taxes and fees in the cart, not on the last screen. If free delivery has a threshold, show how far the shopper is from it.
  2. Offer guest checkout. Let shoppers pay first and create an account afterward with one tap, using the details they already entered.
  3. Cut fields. Use address lookup, remember returning customers, and remove anything you do not need to deliver the order.
  4. Make pages fast. In research commissioned by Google, a 0.1-second improvement in mobile site speed raised conversion rates by 8.4% for retail sites, according to web.dev. Start with the cart and payment pages.
  5. Show delivery dates and slots before checkout. On the product page or in the cart, not after the address step.
  6. Reserve stock during checkout. Hold the unit while the customer pays, so the item cannot sell out between cart and payment.
  7. Validate promo codes and loyalty in the cart. Apply the code or points instantly, say clearly why a code does not work, and make sure the same promotions are live on app and web.
  8. Give payment choices and a second chance. Offer the wallets and local methods your customers use. When a card is declined, keep the cart and offer another method instead of starting over.
  9. Keep one cart across devices. A logged-in shopper should see the same cart on app and web within seconds.

TipBefore changing anything, complete a purchase yourself on a mid-range phone over mobile data, using a promo code and loyalty points. Note every moment you hesitate. That list is usually your first sprint.

Abandoned cart recovery: the Cart Recovery Ladder

Abandoned cart recovery works best as a ladder: start with the lightest, cheapest touch and climb only for shoppers and carts that justify it. The Cart Recovery Ladder has four rungs, each with a clear trigger, timing and consent rule.

RungWhen to use itTimingRules and consentWhat to measure
1. On-site nudgeEvery shopper still on your site or app: saved cart banner, low-stock note, delivery date reminderDuring the session or on the next visitNo extra consent beyond your normal site policies; keep it honest (no fake scarcity)Return-to-cart rate
2. EmailKnown shoppers with an email addressFirst within about an hour, a second around a day later, then stopUS commercial email must follow CAN-SPAM, including a clear opt-outIncremental orders vs control
3. SMS or app pushShoppers who opted in to marketing texts or push; time-sensitive carts (slots, limited stock)Within a few hours, at reasonable local timesMarketing texts need clear prior opt-in consent; honor stop requests at onceIncremental orders and opt-out rate
4. Phone call (human or AI voice agent)High-value carts, or carts stuck on a payment error or delivery question, from customers who agreed to be calledSame day, during business hoursAI-voice marketing calls need prior express written consent in the US; identify the caller and offer an opt-outRecovered value per call vs cost per call

Email is the default rung because it is cheap and well understood. The FTC's CAN-SPAM compliance guide says commercial emails must tell recipients how to opt out, include a valid physical postal address, and honor opt-out requests within 10 business days. Abandoned cart emails are usually commercial, so treat them that way.

Calls carry more risk. In February 2024 the Federal Communications Commission ruled that AI-generated voices count as "artificial" voices under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, so the same consent rules apply as for prerecorded calls; for marketing calls, that means prior express written consent. Collect that consent at checkout or account creation, record it, and check the rules with your counsel for every country you call. This is not legal advice.

Done within those rules, a call is the most personal rung. A shopper with a $600 cart stuck on a declined card or a delivery question often needs a quick answer, not a discount. An outbound agent such as WiseRep AI can run abandoned-cart calls from the same agent that handles inbound service, and hand over to a person when the conversation needs one.

What a good abandoned cart message says

Show the exact items, the current price and stock, and the delivery date. Solve the likely reason for leaving (a link back to a saved cart, the delivery cost, a clear returns line) before offering a discount. Discounts in the first message teach shoppers to abandon on purpose; keep them for a later step and for customers whose history justifies it.

How do you measure recovered revenue honestly?

Measure recovered revenue by comparing shoppers who received recovery messages with a random control group who did not. Only the difference between the two groups is revenue your recovery flow created.

Most dashboards credit every order placed after a reminder as "recovered". Many of those shoppers were coming back anyway, so the number flatters the program and hides the cost of discounts given to people who did not need them.

  1. Hold out a control group. Randomly exclude 10% to 20% of eligible abandoned carts from all recovery messages.
  2. Compare conversion over the same window. For example, orders placed within seven days of abandonment in each group.
  3. Calculate incremental revenue. (Conversion rate of messaged group minus conversion rate of control group) × messaged carts × average order value.
  4. Subtract the cost. Discounts given, messaging and call costs.

An illustrative example: 10,000 messaged carts convert at 9% and the control group converts at 6%. Incremental orders are 3% × 10,000 = 300, worth $27,000 at a $90 order value. The dashboard would have claimed 900 recovered orders; the honest answer is 300. Run the same test on each rung of the Cart Recovery Ladder to see which ones earn their place. Shoppers you win back this way are a retention opportunity too; see how to improve customer retention.

Where should you start?

Start by splitting cart and checkout abandonment by device and step, then fix the largest drop-off before building more recovery messages. Most stores find one step, often delivery cost or account creation, that explains much of the loss.

Then build the Cart Recovery Ladder from the bottom: an honest on-site nudge, a well-timed email, opted-in SMS or push, and calls only for high-value carts with consent. Ecommerce and D2C brands usually see the quickest results here; see how ecommerce and D2C teams approach it. The selling and fulfillment solution shows how one cart, live stock and synced promotions remove the retail-specific reasons, and LyraCX Commerce adds AI cart and checkout nudges on top.

If you would like an outside view first, take the free cart recovery review. We will go through your checkout and win-back flow with you, step by step, and show where carts leak and which rung of the ladder to fix first. Request your cart recovery review.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good cart abandonment rate?

There is no universal good rate, but Baymard Institute's average across 50 studies is about 70%, so most stores lose the majority of carts. Track your own checkout abandonment rate by device and step and aim to lower it over time. A mobile rate far above desktop, or one step with a sharp drop, shows where to work first.

What is the main cause of cart abandonment?

The most common cause is unexpected extra costs. In Baymard Institute's survey of US shoppers who abandoned a checkout, 40% of those not just browsing cited shipping, taxes or fees. Slow delivery, forced account creation and long checkouts follow. Retailers with stores and apps also lose carts to failing promo codes, missing delivery slots and stock that sells out during checkout.

How soon should you send an abandoned cart email?

Send the first abandoned cart email within about an hour, while the shopper still remembers the cart, and a second around a day later. Stop after two or three messages. Test timing against a control group, because the best window depends on your products, price points and how long your customers usually take to decide.

In the US it can be, with the right consent. The FCC ruled in 2024 that AI-generated voices count as artificial voices under the TCPA, so marketing calls using them need prior express written consent. Collect and record consent, call at reasonable hours, identify yourself and offer an opt-out. Check local rules with counsel in every country you call.

What is checkout optimization?

Checkout optimization is improving the steps between cart and payment so more shoppers who start checkout finish it. Typical fixes include showing the full cost early, offering guest checkout, cutting form fields, speeding up pages, adding payment methods, reserving stock during payment and applying promo codes and loyalty points instantly. Each change should be measured against conversion, not opinion.

Knoativ Team

Retail CX Research

The Knoativ editorial team covers identity-led retail strategy, customer data platforms, and the technology behind unified commerce experiences.

Follow on LinkedIn

Filed under

  • Ecommerce strategy
  • Commerce
  • LyraCX Commerce
  • Cart abandonment
  • Checkout

Ready to Know Every Customer?